On December 27, 2025, the St. Paul Community Center on 13th Street in Toledo became the site of sudden violence. Shortly after 3 p.m., police officers responding to reports of gunfire found 36‑year‑old Andrew Shively critically wounded inside the building. Paramedics worked quickly to stabilize him before rushing him to Mercy Health St. Vincent Medical Center, but despite their efforts he later died from his injuries.
The exact details of where the shooting occurred inside the center and how events unfolded have not been released. What is clear is that the attack disrupted a space normally associated with safety and connection. St. Paul Community Center is a hub for youth programs, senior activities, sports, and neighborhood meetings, and the incident during active afternoon hours left residents shaken.
Police secured the area immediately, establishing a perimeter while investigators began gathering evidence. Detectives are reviewing surveillance footage, interviewing witnesses, and analyzing ballistic material to reconstruct the sequence of events. No suspects have been identified, and authorities have appealed for anyone with information to come forward.
For Toledo, the shooting has raised urgent questions about security in public gathering places, especially those serving vulnerable populations. Officials have stressed the importance of vigilance and reporting suspicious behavior, while the center itself is expected to undergo a safety review before reopening.
As the investigation continues, forensic specialists are examining shell casings, digital records, and other evidence to clarify what led to the attack. Police have emphasized that their priority is accountability and transparency, promising updates as significant developments occur.
The death of Andrew Shively has left a community grieving and searching for answers. In the days ahead, Toledo residents are being asked to remain alert, support one another, and cooperate with investigators so that justice can be pursued and peace restored to a neighborhood shaken by tragedy.