A tragic discovery in the quiet rural community of the Town of Magnolia, Wisconsin, claimed the lives of Tamie Borgwardt, 53, and Jeffrey Borgwardt, 54, both lifelong residents of Evansville. On Friday, December 26, 2025, loved ones raised concerns after being unable to reach the couple, prompting the Rock County Sheriff’s Office to conduct a welfare check at their home in the 2300 block of North Marsh Road.
When deputies received no response at the door, they entered the residence and found Tamie and Jeffrey deceased inside. The scene was secured immediately, and the investigation began without delay. Magnolia Township, with its rolling farmland, scattered family homes, and peaceful country roads, suddenly became the center of profound sorrow for a community that has always valued its close ties and neighborly care.
The Rock County Sheriff’s Office responded promptly to the call, arriving at the modest home where Tamie and Jeffrey had built their life together. Deputies noted the absence of any forced entry or immediate signs of disturbance, though the full circumstances surrounding their deaths remain under careful review.
Autopsies were conducted on December 27 and 29, with the Rock County Medical Examiner’s Office working closely with investigators to determine cause and manner of death. As of early January 2026, no official findings have been released, and authorities continue to gather evidence, interview witnesses, and examine the scene in hopes of providing clarity to the grieving family.
Tamie and Jeffrey Borgwardt were known throughout Evansville and the surrounding area for their kindness, quiet generosity, and steady presence in the lives of those around them. They had made their home in the Town of Magnolia, a small township where families often stay rooted for generations, raising children, tending gardens, and supporting one another through the changing seasons.
Their life together reflected the values of rural Wisconsin: hard work, loyalty, and a deep appreciation for the simple joys of community and family. The couple was remembered by neighbors as approachable and warm, always willing to offer a helping hand or share a conversation that left others feeling seen and valued. Their home on North Marsh Road stood as a place of welcome, a reflection of the couple’s gentle and caring nature.
As the investigation continues, the Rock County Sheriff’s Office and Medical Examiner’s Office maintain a measured approach, ensuring every detail is carefully examined before conclusions are drawn. No additional information has been released at this time, and officials have asked for patience as they work to understand what led to this heartbreaking outcome.
The uncertainty surrounding the cause and manner of death only adds to the weight of sorrow carried by those closest to Tamie and Jeffrey, yet the community’s response remains one of compassion and solidarity. In moments like these, Evansville and the Town of Magnolia show their true character, drawing strength from shared memories and the enduring bonds that hold people together.