On November 26, 2025, 18-year-old Emily Finn of West Sayville was fatally shot inside the home of her 17-year-old ex-boyfriend at 134 Shenandoah Boulevard North. Suffolk County Police responded around 11:10 a.m. to a 911 call from the suspect’s parents, discovering Emily deceased from a shotgun wound and the unnamed teen boy critically injured from a self-inflicted facial gunshot.
The incident stemmed from Emily’s visit to return his belongings after their recent breakup, with no prior domestic history reported at the address. Officers secured the two-story residence amid a heavy police presence, yellow tape fluttering in the autumn wind as detectives processed the scene for evidence.
The teen suspect, who survived and faces second-degree murder charges, will be arraigned once medically cleared, according to Suffolk County Homicide Squad Commander Lt. Kevin Beyrer. Emily was pronounced dead at the scene, her loss compounding the shock in a neighborhood unaccustomed to such violence.
The Suffolk County Police Department’s investigation continues, with no motive beyond the breakup disclosed and no additional suspects sought. Authorities emphasize the absence of prior 911 calls involving the pair, underscoring the sudden escalation. Community leaders urge resources for teen mental health, as the case highlights risks in young relationships.
Emily Finn grew up in West Sayville’s welcoming coastal community, where family beach days and school friendships nurtured her vibrant curiosity from elementary years at Sayville Manor. She embraced Long Island’s suburban rhythm, forming bonds through local events that highlighted her thoughtful empathy.
As a recent Sayville High School graduate in June 2025, Emily pursued college studies with enthusiasm, balancing classes with a passion for creative outlets like photography and volunteering at animal shelters.
Her academic path reflected determination, often sharing insights on social media about personal growth amid Suffolk County’s supportive educational landscape. Peers admired her ability to uplift during group projects and casual hangouts.
Emily’s world centered on her devoted family, where she cherished her role as daughter and sister, filling weekends with shared meals and drives along Fire Island’s shores. She offered steady encouragement through milestones, her home a haven of laughter in West Sayville’s rhythms.